Humble Pie Butter Tart Factory & Pizzeria - Discover Muskoka: Plan Your Trip

Discover Muskoka: Plan Your Trip

Close
Home
Search
Menu
Lake of Bays

Humble Pie Butter Tart Factory & Pizzeria

Address:
6 Bay St., Baysville, ON

About

Celebrating 15 Years In Muskoka

Baysville’s beloved bakery, the Humble Pie Butter Tart Factory & Pizzeria, is located in the heart of downtown Baysville. They offer a selection of delicious home-style pies, pastries, buttermilk scones, cookies, breads, and seasonal specialties. Their most popular culinary delight is the infamous Humble Pie Butter Tart! Don’t miss out on their savory selection of quiche, meat pies, Shepherd’s pies, casseroles, and hand-crafted Italian-style pizzas. If you’re in a hurry, they offer grab & go breakfast sandwiches, grilled paninis, deli-style sandwiches, pizza slices, cold drinks, coffee, tea & hot chocolate. The bakery partners up with local artisans retailing Fairy Falls Sugarbush maple syrup, Smith Family Funny Farm and Poppa Jim’s organic honeys, Muskoka Roastery Coffee Co., Muskoka Wild Brine craft condiments, and a variety of sourdough from Queen St Sourdough.  Limited gluten-free options available. It’s a busy little bakery, so it’s a good idea to order in advance to make sure you get your favorites when touring Muskoka.